Table of Contents
Australian Mining Stocks: A Cautious Landscape Amidst Valuation Opportunities
Australian mining stocks have faced significant challenges recently, underperforming the ASX 200 index by over 30% since October 2023, despite a rise in commodity prices. According to Citi, the sector’s valuations are now particularly attractive, with large miners trading at just 0.76 times their discounted cash flow (DCF), indicating a potential opportunity for long-term investors. However, ongoing global economic uncertainties—including potential US tariffs and diminishing demand outside of China—are causing analysts to advise caution for those seeking immediate gains.
China: A Mixed Outlook
China plays a pivotal role in stabilising the bulk commodities market, particularly regarding iron ore. Data from Citi shows that China’s pig iron production increased by 0.7% year-on-year in April, with a year-to-date rise of 0.8%, helping to sustain iron ore prices. Moreover, China’s monetary policy is becoming more accommodative, with money supply (M2) and Total Social Financing growing consistently for five months, offering a potential boost to steel demand until 2026.
Despite these positive signs, China’s economy faces hurdles. The residential property sector, historically a significant consumer of steel, continues to struggle. In April, housing starts and completions dropped sharply by 22% and 28% year-on-year, respectively, resulting in year-to-date declines of 24% and 17%. Although property sales have only slightly decreased, the destocking cycle may be nearing its conclusion, which could foster a tentative recovery in construction activity.
Citi suggests that recent improvements in the supply-demand dynamics since May 2024 could prompt new housing projects, potentially enhancing steel and iron ore demand by late 2025 or early 2026. Additionally, infrastructure investment shows promising trends, with excavator sales up 18% year-on-year in April, indicating robust non-residential construction activity. However, there are signs of softening demand on the horizon, with Chinese infrastructure contractors’ order books down by 6% from the previous year, signalling possible dips in steel demand for the fiscal year 2025. A resurgence in orders could help shift market sentiment in favour of iron ore and steel prices as projects move from planning to execution.
A recovery in property values may also generate a wealth effect that boosts consumer spending and, consequently, manufacturing activity, though this remains a longer-term expectation.
Global Economic Headwinds
Beyond China, the global economic environment is increasingly precarious. Citi’s economists forecast that global growth will decelerate to 2.3% in 2025, down from 2.8% in 2024, with advanced economies struggling to achieve growth above 1%. The incremental introduction of US tariffs threatens to disrupt global trade flows significantly. A surge of nearly 30% in US import volumes from October 2023 to March 2024 has artificially inflated demand as businesses stockpiled inventory ahead of the impending tariffs, but this is expected to lead to a decline in demand as tariffs take full effect.
Manufacturing activity remains precarious, with the Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) hovering near the critical 50-point mark, indicating a brink between expansion and contraction. Although the services PMI is still above 50, it shows signs of weakening, hinting at broader economic fragility. European markets, particularly Germany, are also showing signs of contraction-related challenges.
Base metals and oil, heavily reliant on global demand, appear particularly vulnerable, while bulk commodities like iron ore demonstrate resilience in light of China’s supportive policies.
Valuation Opportunities vs. Timing Challenges
The substantial underperformance of the Australian mining sector has led to historically low valuations, with the average price-to-DCF ratio for major miners now sitting at 0.76x. While this presents a chance for value-oriented investors, recent downgrades—such as Citi’s reduction of South32 (ASX: S32) from Buy to Neutral with a target price of $3.40—reflect caution regarding metals demand beyond China’s borders.
For investors intrigued by these attractive valuations, understanding the right timing for market entry is crucial. The ongoing tug-of-war between Chinese policy support and global economic pressures highlights the complexity of the landscape. While Chinese infrastructures and monetary policies may boost demand in mid-2026, immediate risks stemming from tariff-induced demand fluctuations and slowing global growth present significant hurdles.
In the near term, iron ore appears less vulnerable compared to base metals, which face greater risks from weakening demand in developed markets.
Conclusion
Citi’s comprehensive analysis presents a mining sector at a critical juncture. The appealing valuations suggest a golden opportunity for long-term investments, particularly in bulk commodity producers linked to China’s economic performance. Nonetheless, the risks tied to US tariffs, uncertain global demand, and the irregular recovery in China necessitate a cautious investment strategy.
Investors may want to wait for stronger indications—such as a sustained recovery in Chinese infrastructure projects or stabilisation in global manufacturing—before committing to the sector. Currently, the mining industry’s narrative is one of trapped value amidst uncertainty. The path forward for Australian mining will depend significantly on how these varied factors unfold over the next 12 to 18 months.
