Table of Contents
Overview of Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) Valuation Concerns
In recent discussions within investment circles, Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA) has drawn attention for being labelled "overvalued" by several fund managers and investment commentators. Below is a summary of insights from various experts regarding CBA’s valuation.
Commentary on CBA’s Valuation
- Financial Times (June 19, 2025): Rupert Mitchell comments, “This surge is not fully supported by fundamentals.”
- News.com.au (June 8, 2025): Alan Hull mentions, “Smart money is not buying CBA — it’s seriously overvalued.”
- Stocks Down Under (June 6, 2025): Nick Sundich reports that analysts see the stock as overvalued, with a target price suggesting a ~40% discount.
- InvestorDaily (May 20, 2025): Paul Moore states, “Super fund behaviour has inflated CBA’s price beyond logic.”
- Livewire Markets (May 29, 2025): Simon Mawhinney expressed, “I’d rather stick pins in my eyes than buy CBA.”
- Morningstar (May 2025): Matthew Haupt describes CBA as “the most expensive bank in the world,” calling its valuation unjustifiable.
- Motley Fool Australia (January 16, 2025): Firetrail Investments anticipates that CBA is “30% overvalued,” warning of likely valuation compression.
- Reuters (February 10, 2025): An unnamed analyst notes that CBA trades at 26x forward earnings, more than double its peers.
- Plato Investment Management (December 2024): Dr Don Hamson highlights that CBA is “trading at growth multiples without growth.”
- Market Index (July 16, 2024): L1 Capital observes it has the “most expensive valuation ever” at a ~60% premium to peers.
- The Australian (October 2024): Phil King asserts that CBA’s valuation is unsustainable.
Despite this chorus of concern, some investors remain bullish. The prevailing question remains: why do investors wrestle with reality in valuations?
Demand vs. Supply: An Investor’s Perspective
As stock prices rise, they indicate that demand exceeds supply. One investor’s straightforward approach is to consider:
- Increasing Prices: More demand than supply means it’s advisable to hold onto the stock.
- Decreasing Prices: More supply than demand suggests a need to sell or avoid the stock.
Applying this philosophy over the last 13 months, CBA has consistently shown strength, establishing itself as a top uptrend during that period.
CBA vs. Current Market Trends
Current evaluations indicate CBA’s robust performance, reflected in recent uptrends:
Uptrends Scan List
Below are notable companies, including CBA, experiencing upward trends:
| Company | Code | Last Price | 1 Month % | 1 Year % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commonwealth Bank of Australia | CBA | $184.35 | +6.7% | +45.2% |
| Autosports Group | ASG | $2.23 | +5.7% | +3.7% |
| Goodman Group | GMG | $34.59 | +8.2% | -3.0% |
Downtrends Scan List
Conversely, certain companies are in decline, delineating the current market struggles:
| Company | Code | Last Price | 1 Month % | 1 Year % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AGL Energy | AGL | $9.97 | -2.4% | -4.7% |
| IDP Education | IEL | $3.52 | -59.0% | -77.4% |
| Kogan.Com | KGN | $3.67 | -8.3% | -17.9% |
Conclusion
Whether CBA’s valuation concerns hold any merit in the long run remains to be seen. Investment strategies often pivot on market sentiment and individual risk tolerance. CBA’s overvalued tag is contradicted by its unabated uptrend, raising a pertinent question: can fundamental valuation concerns outweigh demand-driven price movements?
As with any investment decision, prospective investors are encouraged to perform their research and consider broader market conditions before taking the plunge into stocks such as CBA.
