Table of Contents
ASX 200 Reaches Historic Heights Amid Mixed Market Signals
Last Friday, the S&P/ASX 200 surged by 0.73%, closing above 8,900—a record achievement for the index. This represents the 16th record high of the year, capping off a remarkable 22% surge since the lows observed on Liberation Day (April 7), with year-to-date gains now at 9.6% and twelve-month returns reaching 12%.
Despite this impressive performance, there is growing concern among investors about whether to take profits at these elevated levels. The timing is particularly sensitive, coinciding with August’s earnings reporting season. Current consensus anticipates a modest earnings decline of 1.7%, primarily influenced by falling commodity prices, uncertainties surrounding China’s economic growth, and concerns over tariffs. Even with the market achieving all-time highs, several underlying issues prompt caution.
It’s crucial to note that markets frequently reflect forward expectations rather than present circumstances. Predictions suggest potential interest rate cuts and projected earnings growth of 5.3% for FY26 and 7.4% for FY27.
A Look at Historical Record Highs
Since 2000, the ASX 200 has reached 125 weekly record highs, averaging new peaks approximately every 11 weeks (or 9.3% of the time). A graphical representation of this trend shows that record highs tend to cluster, continuing until a significant downturn occurs.
Market Performance Post-Record Highs
To gauge the ASX’s performance following previous record highs, we analysed data from 126 weekly peaks, excluding instances lacking sufficient forward-looking data.
| 1 Month | 6 Months | 1 Year | 2 Years | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Average | -0.4% | 2.7% | 6.4% | 5.7% |
| Median | 0.4% | 3.3% | 10.6% | 4.9% |
| % Higher | 56% | 66% | 65% | 56% |
While the statistics indicate generally positive trends across various timeframes, it is noteworthy that they are heavily influenced by the bull market between 2003 and 2007, during which the ASX 200 rose by 145% before experiencing a substantial decline.
Looking Ahead
Market analyst Richard Coppleson from Bell Potter warns that the market appears "stretched" as it enters the historically volatile August-September timeframe. Sell-offs of 3% or more typically occur every 1.5 to 2 months, and with more than three months since the last dip, Coppleson attributes a 75% likelihood to a potential ~5% correction within the next two months.
Nevertheless, he suggests any downturn could present a buying opportunity, citing a recurring trend observed over his 30-year career: when markets pull back, available cash is often reinvested aggressively. Anticipated rate cuts from the Federal Reserve, along with fund managers’ underexposure to equities, may further create dynamics that compel buying.
Coppleson predicts a sell-off may materialise from mid-September through early October, with October historically positioned as a month marking significant recoveries after initial downturns. He notes that fund managers who miss this potential dip could face considerable underperformance during the typically strong quarter for equities that follows.
Conclusion
The investment landscape remains optimistic, as major companies such as Commonwealth Bank, JB Hi-Fi, and various Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) generally meet market expectations, notwithstanding some concerns over stock valuations. Given the recent ascension and the typical seasonal weakness in September, a long-desired correction seems more probable. However, barring any extraordinary catalysts, upward momentum appears to be the prevailing trend.
